Notice: The GasBuddy® site will be temporarily unavailable from 11pm CST to 5am CST on July 8-9 for routine maintenance .

Top 10 Gas Station & Cheap Fuel Prices in New Castle, IN

QuickPix

Shell 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star Icon
 41
2200 S Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN
$3.05
Price Reporter Icon visitor1 Day Ago

Amenities

C-Store
Car Wash
Pay at Pump
Restrooms
Air Pump
ATM
Loyalty Discount
Beer

Reviews

stgbotmem902's avatar image
stgbotmem902
Mar 11 2020
Great Review Icon

Clean, well lit


View Full Station Details
 Details
Conoco

Conoco 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star IconEmpty Star Icon
 23
709 S Main St
New Castle, IN
$3.19
Price Reporter Icon visitor1 Day Ago

Amenities

No amenities found.


Reviews

stgbotme1008's avatar image
stgbotme1008
Sep 12 2023
Okay Review Icon

Gas buddy card does not work here. But they do have cheap Diesel fuel prices sometimes where its worth to fill here without the GasBuddy card.


View Full Station Details
 Details
Marathon

Amoco 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star Icon
 12
2306 Spring St
New Castle, IN
- - -

Amenities

Propane
C-Store
Car Wash
Pay at Pump
Restaurant
Restrooms
Air Pump
Payphone
Lotto
Beer
Wine

Reviews

Duke707's avatar image
Duke707
Dec 03 2016
Great Review Icon

very friendly


View Full Station Details
 Details
Casey's

Casey's 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star Icon
 65
3100 S Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN
- - -

Amenities

Propane
C-Store
Pay at Pump
Restrooms
Air Pump
ATM

Reviews

stgbotme1254's avatar image
stgbotme1254
May 12 2023
Great Review Icon

Always go here


View Full Station Details
 Details
Marathon

Broad Mart 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star Icon
 77
1709 E Broad St
New Castle, IN
- - -

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
Membership Pricing
Propane
C-Store
Pay at Pump
Restrooms
Air Pump
ATM
Loyalty Discount
Lotto

Reviews

dakotart1's avatar image
dakotart1
Feb 05 2017
Great Review Icon

Ok


View Full Station Details
 Details
Speedway

Speedway 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star Icon
 41
1801 Broad St
New Castle, IN
- - -

Amenities

C-Store
Pay at Pump
Restrooms
Air Pump

Reviews

stgbotme1029's avatar image
stgbotme1029
May 15 2023
Great Review Icon

Always have a good experience. the staff is always courteous and very patient


View Full Station Details
 Details
Flying J

Flying J 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star Icon
 278
5300 IN-3
Spiceland, IN
- - -

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
Propane
C-Store
Pay at Pump
Restaurant
Restrooms
ATM
Truck Stop
Loyalty Discount
Lotto

Reviews

kitkat1970's avatar image
kitkat1970
Feb 03 2017
Great Review Icon

great place


View Full Station Details
 Details
Ricker's

GetGo 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star Icon
 30
1206 W Mill
Middletown, IN
- - -

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
Membership Pricing
Pay at Pump
Restaurant
Restrooms
ATM
Loyalty Discount
Lotto
Beer

Reviews

stgbotme1008's avatar image
stgbotme1008
Sep 14 2023
Great Review Icon

Gas prices at this location seem to be a bit on the high side lately. I like this location, its convenient, friendly, and clean.


View Full Station Details
 Details
Marathon

Marathon 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star Icon
 20
1909 S Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN
- - -

Amenities

Pay at Pump
Air Pump

Reviews

stgbotmem191's avatar image
stgbotmem191
Nov 23 2021
Great Review Icon

Great


View Full Station Details
 Details
Speedway

Speedway 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star IconEmpty Star Icon
 14
213 W Main St
Knightstown, IN
- - -

Amenities

C-Store
Air Pump

Reviews

stgbotmem191's avatar image
stgbotmem191
Mar 12 2018
Great Review Icon

Nice station


View Full Station Details
 Details
Click here to earn instant savings of up to $10 every tank!
Click here to download the GasBuddy App and start saving today!

You Are Here

 Home Gas Prices Indiana New Castle