Notice: The GasBuddy® site will be temporarily unavailable from 11pm CST to 5am CST on July 8-9 for routine maintenance .
 Home Gas Prices New York Sullivan County

Top 10 Gas Station & Cheap Fuel Prices in Sullivan County, NY

CITGO

CITGO 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star IconEmpty Star Icon
 13
66 Pleasant St
Monticello, NY

Amenities

C-Store
Pay at Pump
Air Pump
Payphone
Loyalty Discount

Reviews

stgbotmem813's avatar image
stgbotmem813
Nov 20 2022
Great Review Icon

Friendly attendants. Quick service.


View Full Station Details
 Details
Combined Energy Services

Combined Energy Services 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star Icon
 8
276 E Broadway
Monticello, NY

Amenities

Propane
Pay at Pump
Air Pump
Loyalty Discount
Full Service

Reviews

stgbotmem800's avatar image
stgbotmem800
Jul 28 2023
Great Review Icon

The only full service station around! They also have the cheapest propane refill, plus they weigh their tanks they are filling, they dont fill by gallons so you get a full tank of propane, unlike the tank exchange at gas stations


View Full Station Details
 Details
Sunoco

Sunoco 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star IconEmpty Star Icon
 4
360 E Broadway
Monticello, NY

Amenities

Pay at Pump

Reviews

No reviews found for this station.


View Full Station Details
 Details
Mobil

Gulf 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star Icon
 8
519 Broadway
Monticello, NY

Amenities

C-Store
Pay at Pump
Air Pump
ATM
Loyalty Discount

Reviews

stgbotmem778's avatar image
stgbotmem778
Jun 18 2021
Okay Review Icon

Average station


View Full Station Details
 Details
Gulf

Quality Gas & C Stores 

Full Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star IconEmpty Star IconEmpty Star Icon
 10
5 Jefferson St
Monticello, NY

Amenities

Propane
C-Store
Pay at Pump
Air Pump
ATM
Beer

Reviews

stgbotmem97's avatar image
stgbotmem97
Jun 27 2023
Bad Review Icon

will not accept gas buddy card


View Full Station Details
 Details
Mobil

Mobil 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star IconEmpty Star Icon
 8
210 N Main St
Liberty, NY

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
Loyalty Discount

Reviews

stgbotmem930's avatar image
stgbotmem930
Apr 17 2023
Okay Review Icon

Ok


View Full Station Details
 Details
Mobil

Mobil 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconEmpty Star IconEmpty Star Icon
 1
933 NY-17B
Mongaup Valley, NY

Amenities

C-Store
Pay at Pump
Restaurant
Restrooms
Air Pump
ATM
Loyalty Discount

Reviews

stgbotmem25's avatar image
stgbotmem25
Apr 07 2023
Okay Review Icon

Average


View Full Station Details
 Details
Shell

Shell 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconHalf-filled Star IconEmpty Star Icon
 14
20A Dorrer Dr
Callicoon, NY

Amenities

C-Store
Restaurant
Restrooms

Reviews

stgbotmem25's avatar image
stgbotmem25
Jul 28 2021
Okay Review Icon

Station gas pumps, store and restaurant have reopened.


View Full Station Details
 Details
Sunoco

Sunoco 

Full Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconFull Star IconFull Star Icon
 1
120 Kirks Rd
Narrowsburg, NY

Amenities

No amenities found.


Reviews

stgbotmem930's avatar image
stgbotmem930
May 19 2023
Okay Review Icon

Average


View Full Station Details
 Details
CITGO

CITGO 

Full Star IconHalf-filled Star IconEmpty Star IconEmpty Star IconEmpty Star Icon
 3
5 Main St
Livingston Manor, NY

Amenities

C-Store
Loyalty Discount

Reviews

stgbotme1058's avatar image
stgbotme1058
Mar 30 2026
Okay Review Icon

Ok


View Full Station Details
 Details
Click here to earn instant savings of up to $10 every tank!
Click here to download the GasBuddy App and start saving today!

You Are Here

 Home Gas Prices New York Sullivan County