Notice: The GasBuddy^® site will be temporarily unavailable from 11pm CST to 5am CST on July 8-9 for routine maintenance .

Top 10 Gas Station & Cheap Fuel Prices in West Islip, NY

Select fuel type

Show Map

CITGO

410 Montauk Hwy
West Islip, NY

$2.79

DataFeed10 Hours Ago

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount

C-Store

Pay at Pump

Restrooms

Air Pump

ATM

Reviews

stgbotmem409
Dec 25 2021

Nice place.

View Full Station Details

Details

Mobil

268 Higbie Ln
West Islip, NY

- - -

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount

C-Store

Pay at Pump

Restrooms

Air Pump

ATM

Loyalty Discount

Reviews

badger445
Jan 03 2017

Tight parking lot

View Full Station Details

Details

7-Eleven

425 Union Blvd
West Islip, NY

- - -

Amenities

C-Store

Pay at Pump

Restaurant

Restrooms

Air Pump

ATM

Reviews

stgbotmem409
Aug 25 2023

Big

View Full Station Details

Details

Shell

958 Montauk Hwy
West Islip, NY

- - -

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount

C-Store

Pay at Pump

Restrooms

Air Pump

ATM

Beer

Full Service

Reviews

stgbotmem446
Jan 04 2023

Nice place.

View Full Station Details

Details

USA

225 Higbie Ln
West Islip, NY

- - -

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount

C-Store

Pay at Pump

Air Pump

ATM

Service Station

Loyalty Discount

Reviews

stgbotmem446
Sep 09 2023

Nice

View Full Station Details

Details

America's Petroleum

455 Montauk Hwy
West Islip, NY

- - -

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount

C-Store

Pay at Pump

Restrooms

Air Pump

Payphone

Service Station

Reviews

stgbotme1201
Aug 13 2023

This place sucks, rude attendants and they dont accept the GasBuddy card.

View Full Station Details

Details

Mobil

409 Montauk Hwy
West Islip, NY

- - -

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount

Propane

Pay at Pump

Restrooms

Air Pump

Service Station

Loyalty Discount

Reviews

anthony921
Dec 01 2016

Great staff at this location, very nice folks.

View Full Station Details

Details

Exxon

570 Sunrise Hwy
West Islip, NY

- - -

Amenities

Propane

C-Store

Pay at Pump

Restaurant

Restrooms

Air Pump

ATM

Reviews

stgbotmem364
Apr 07 2023

Big

View Full Station Details

Details

Mobil

236 Bay Shore Rd
Bay Shore, NY

- - -

Amenities

C-Store

Pay at Pump

Restrooms

Reviews

stgbotmem446
Mar 20 2023

Nice place.

View Full Station Details

Details

Delta

305 Union Blvd
West Islip, NY

- - -

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount

C-Store

Pay at Pump

Restrooms

Air Pump

ATM

Reviews

stgbotmem370
Sep 24 2023

Nice

View Full Station Details

Details

Top 10 Gas Station & Cheap Fuel Prices in West Islip, NY

CITGO

Amenities

Reviews

Mobil

Amenities

Reviews

7-Eleven

Amenities

Reviews

Shell

Amenities

Reviews

USA

Amenities

Reviews

America's Petroleum

Amenities

Reviews

Mobil

Amenities

Reviews

Exxon

Amenities

Reviews

Mobil

Amenities

Reviews

Delta

Amenities

Reviews

Find Cheap Gas Prices in the US

You Are Here