Top 10 Gas Station & Cheap Fuel Prices in Sheboygan, WI

The gas station is now open as CITGO. Currently, its gas price is lowest in the town.

This place is currently closed. 1/16/2026

The owner is incredibly rude and acts like buying something there is an inconvenience to him. My entire family will no longer stop there because he has been rude to each of us. I would walk 10 miles in the snow with a gas can if I ran out of gas vs. ever giving him my business ever again!

Does not honor BP credit card discount.

maintain their brand well...

this location is unusual with easy access going north or south since the major east-west streets are not close.the gas prices are in the middle of the range for the town.

Always friendly staff.

Best gas prices in the area consistently and they have race fuel! ⛽️

Thanks for the free popcorn