Shell in Athens (4099 Jefferson Rd)

They have good coffee and the best biscuits (morning only) ever. Customer service is sporadic.

Be careful, but this station pretty reliably has the lowest "brand name" gas prices in the area. When you count the 5 cent discount from Fuel Rewards (or 10 cents if you shop enough at Kroger) along with the 10% discount using the Shell credit card, it's a good price for top quality gas (gasoline + additives package).The ATM inside is reliable, with a $2.25 fee.