Notice: The GasBuddy^® site will be temporarily unavailable from 11pm CST to 5am CST on July 8-9 for routine maintenance .

Atlantis Fresh Market in Bethpage (486 N WANTAGH AVE)

Atlantis Fresh Market

(12)

486 N WANTAGH AVE
Bethpage, NY

1 (516) 986-4344

Open 24 Hours

Station Prices

Regular

Midgrade

Premium

- - -

Station Ratings

3.3

Overall Rating

Features & Amenities

Membership Pricing

Propane

C-Store

Pay at Pump

Restaurant

Restrooms

Air Pump

ATM

Loyalty Discount

Lotto

Beer

Wine

Reviews

stgbotmem370
Sep 21 2022

Gas station does not have e85.

stgbotmem391
Feb 08 2018

Average station, good service

JGMAGIC
May 15 2017

Nice people

These reviews are the subjective opinion of a GasBuddy member and not of GasBuddy LLC

Stations Near This Location

Mobil
0.77mi

295 Central Ave
Bethpage, NY

- - -

Amenities

C-Store

Pay at Pump

Restrooms

Air Pump

Service Station

Reviews

stgbotmem446
Jun 25 2022

Good prices and location

View Full Station Details

Details

Shell
0.87mi

3730 Hempstead Tpke
Levittown, NY

- - -

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount

C-Store

Pay at Pump

ATM

Lotto

Reviews

stgbotme1201
Jan 26 2026

Nice station

View Full Station Details

Details

QuickChek
0.89mi

104

3965 Hempstead Trnpk
Bethpage, NY

- - -

Amenities

C-Store

Pay at Pump

Restaurant

Restrooms

Air Pump

ATM

Lotto

Beer

Reviews

stgbotmem364
Feb 13 2026

Good prices. Decent food.

View Full Station Details

Details

Speedway
0.89mi

3924 Hempstead Tpke
Plainedge, NY

- - -

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount

C-Store

Pay at Pump

Restrooms

Air Pump

ATM

Loyalty Discount

Reviews

stgbotme1201
Jun 04 2023

debit should be same price as cash but its not

View Full Station Details

Details

BP
0.94mi

4000 HEMPSTEAD TPKE
Bethpage, NY

- - -

Amenities

C-Store

Pay at Pump

Restrooms

Air Pump

Payphone

ATM

Truck Stop

Reviews

stgbotmem446
Aug 19 2023

clean for the most part, very nice workers.

View Full Station Details

Details

Atlantis Fresh Market in Bethpage (486 N WANTAGH AVE)